My lumber delivery driver told me this week that I'm the only shop he knows of that doesn't always use melamine for their cabinet boxes. And he asked me if people complain that I don't use melamine. Wow. I wasn't aware that people still think of melamine as a good thing...especially here in Portland where we pay special attention to environmental concerns.
I have three main gripes about melamine.
First, it isn't a 100 year product. It's particle board with a thin layer of plastic bonded to it. Fasteners tend to pull out of particle board, and it swells horribly when and if it gets wet. You can't repair it either. It either looks ugly when you chip/crack/soak it, or you replace it.
Second, that thin layer of plastic disqualifies the waste from being recycled with other wood products. Also, more waste is generated within the shop because the offall isn't as versatile for use in the cabinetmaking process.
Finally, there's the chemical thing. There's the melamine and the formaldehyde. I can source a no-added-formaldehyde melamine product, but it's about twice the cost of standard melamine.
Saratoga Woodworks' standard materials include formaldehyde free (NAUF/CARB compliant) plywood products with water based and low VOC finishes.
We have the capability to use many Green products you may beinterested in, from wheat board to reclaimed material to Paperstone countertops.